• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Natural Pastures Cheese Company

Canadian Artisan Cheese Maker

  • Where to Find Us
    • Our Cheese Shop
  • Our Cheeses
    • Our Cow Cheese Collection
      • Aged Farmhouse Cheese
      • Pacific Parmesan – a Canadian cheese for your Italian style dinners
      • Comox Brie
      • Comox Brie
      • Camembert
      • Pacific Wildfire Verdelait
      • The Amsterdammer Cheese
    • Our Water Buffalo Cheese Collection
      • Bufetta – our Feta upgrade
      • Bocconcini di Bufala
      • Water Buffalo Colby
      • Mozzarella di Bufala
      • Water buffalo paneer
      • Mt. Becher Trail Water Buffalo Washed Rind
      • Water Buffalo Cream Cheese
  • Contact Us
    • Wholesale Contacts
    • Nutritional Facts
    • Brand Standard Booklet
    • Is Natural Pastures Package GDR compliant? Q & A
    • Cheese Power Point 2026
      • Caring for Canadians: Why Pasteurization Matters in Our Cheese
  • Blog
    • Grilling Cheese: A Primer
    • Baked Brie Party Trick!
    • Recipes & Pairings
    • Tea & Cheese
    • Wine & Cheese
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Buy BC
    • Win
    • Vancouver Island Experiences
  • Cheese Academy
  • Show Search
Hide Search
Home/Our Cheeses/Our Water Buffalo Cheese Collection/Water Buffalo Colby

Water Buffalo Colby

Smooth, mild and wonderfully creamy, with a pleasant tartness reminiscent of a good cheddar, our Water Buffalo Colby is a familiar favourite made a little more special with rich Vancouver Island water buffalo milk.

Made in small batches, this cheese has a supple texture, full creamy mouthfeel and a slight cheddar flavour balanced by a subtle savoury tang. It is approachable and easy to enjoy, while still having enough character to make it distinctly different from an everyday Colby or Jack.

Our water buffalo milk naturally contains A2 beta-casein protein, rather than the A1 beta-casein commonly found in conventional cow’s milk. Emerging research suggests that dairy containing only A2 beta-casein may be more comfortable to digest for some people who experience digestive symptoms after drinking conventional milk. It is important to remember that A2 dairy still contains lactose and milk protein, so it is not a lactose-free product or an alternative for those with a milk allergy.

Water buffalo milk is naturally rich and gives this Colby its wonderfully creamy texture and satisfying depth of flavour.

Slice it for sandwiches and burgers, cube it for lunch boxes and cheese boards, melt it into grilled cheese, quesadillas or omelettes, or add it to macaroni and cheese for an extra layer of creamy richness.

It is also a wonderful family cheese — mild enough for younger palates while offering the creamy texture and gentle tang that cheese lovers appreciate.

Made with water buffalo milk from Vancouver Island farms, our Water Buffalo Colby brings together local milk, small-batch craftsmanship and an exceptionally smooth eating experience.

Small Batch. A2 Water Buffalo Milk. Creamy. Buttery. Gently Tart. Distinctly Vancouver Island.

Primary Sidebar

search

Join us on social

RSS feed: Recipes and Pairings Recipes and Pairings

  • Beaver Meadow Farms: The Farming Roots Behind Natural Pastures Cheese
    The operations of Beaver Meadow Farms and Natural Pastures Beef have now come to an end, but their history remains deeply connected to the beginnings of Natural Pastures Cheese Company, the Smith family, and generations of farming in the Comox Valley. Natural Pastures Cheese Company no longer sells beef along side our cheese, in our […]
  • Michael Tchao’s Journey Around Vancouver Island: Water Buffalo, Mozzarella, and a Taste of Place
    On Vancouver Island, food has a way of carrying the story of where it comes from. For Michael Tchao, his journey around the Island is not just about travel. It is about meeting the people, seeing the land, and understanding the care and the science, that goes into food before it ever reaches a plate. […]
  • Amsterdammer: The Summer Cheese That Fights With No One
    Inspired by a German-style butter cheese, our Amsterdammer is mild, creamy, and wonderfully approachable. It has a gentle richness and a smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture that makes it a favourite for young and old. Kids love it because it is mild and creamy. Adults love it because it pairs beautifully with so many foods and drinks. […]

Cheese Making with Master Cheese Maker Paul Sutter

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mvyOpNdwvW0

Welcome from Owner Doug Smith

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b_eYFPy5nZ0

Our Artisan Cheese Shop at Natural Pastures

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFqbwleRf6c&t=341s

Footer

Copyright © 2026 Natural Pastures Cheese Company · Privacy Policy · Website design by The Communication Studio

  • Where to Find Us
  • Home
  • News & Events
  • Our Cheeses
  • Cheese Academy